Rufino's Pizza Menu (Update 2026)

Rufino's Pizza in St. Augustine serves a mouth-watering array of New York-style pizza that captivates the locals. The menu showcases classic cheese pies available in 16" and 18" sizes, featuring crispy crusts. Peppered with options like pepperoni, sausage, and even a white spinach variant, each slice delivers a burst of flavor.

Garlic knots are a standout item, with sizes catering for both small and larger appetites, while the salads provide a fresh counterpoint to the hearty pizzas. Dipping sauces elevate the pizza experience, offering choices like homemade marinara and their special garlic oil sauce. You can grab a bite from 11:30 AM to 4 PM when the XXL slices are available, perfect for a quick lunch.

Rufino's Pizza Menu image 1
Rufino's Pizza Menu image 2
Rufino's Pizza Menu image 3

Featured Dishes

Pepperoni Rolls
Pepperoni Rolls
Pizza Margherita
Pizza Margherita
Pizza Slice
Pizza Slice
Fresh Daily
Fresh Daily
16 Pepperoni
16 Pepperoni
White Spinach Pizza
White Spinach Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Garlic Knots
Garlic Knots
Rufino's Pizza

Rufino's Pizza Interior, Food, Ambiance

The interior of Rufino's Pizza reflects a cozy, welcoming vibe typical of neighborhood pizza joints in New York. Bright colors and vibrant decor make it a cheerful spot for pizza lovers of all ages. Counter seating allows the aroma of freshly baked pies to waft through the air invitingly.

The communal food court setting adds a casual, friendly atmosphere where diners can relax and enjoy their meals. Whether grabbing a quick slice on the go or sitting down to enjoy a full pie with family, Rufino's Pizza caters to every dining scenario.

Rufino's Pizza

About Rufino's Pizza Food and Specialties

The heart of Rufino's Pizza lies in its dedication to quality ingredients and techniques that reflect true New York pizza culture. Each pizza begins with fresh dough, hand-stretched to achieve that ideal balance of crispness and chewiness.

Specialties like the stuffed pizza layer flavors inside and out, while the grandma slice appeals to those looking for a more traditional, square-shaped option. Add in the delicious garlic knots, which accompany nearly every pizza order, and diners find a comforting familiarity that keeps them coming back for more. Vegetarian options like the spinach and ricotta pizza cater to diverse palates, making this an inclusive spot for friends and family gatherings.

Rufino's Pizza

Rufino's Pizza commits to providing the highest quality food while fostering a sense of community. Specializing in New York-style pizza, the restaurant emphasizes fresh ingredients and bold flavors. The team works diligently to ensure every pizza is crafted to perfection, with an emphasis on crispy crusts and rich toppings.

The vision for Rufino's expands beyond just serving pizza; it aims to create a gathering place where friends and families can come together.

Each meal served instills joy and a taste of home, resonating with both locals and tourists alike. As Rufino's continues to grow, it cherishes the role it plays in the lives of its customers, becoming synonymous with good food and good times.